WAV or AAC: Which Recording Format Should You Use?
On this page
For most voice memos, lectures and meetings, record in AAC. The files are small and speech stays clear. Record in WAV when you plan to edit the audio heavily, hand it to someone who will mix it, or need the exact original samples. If your recorder offers both, as TapeSail does, you pick one before you record, and you can convert between the two later.
That's the short answer. The rest of this guide explains what each format does, how much space each one takes on a phone, and the few cases where the choice really matters.
What's the difference between WAV and AAC?
WAV stores audio as uncompressed PCM. Every sample the microphone captured is written to the file as it is [1]. Nothing is thrown away, so the file is large.
AAC is a lossy codec. The encoder uses a model of human hearing to drop sound you are unlikely to notice, then stores what's left in far less space [1]. A lossless file decodes back to exactly what went in. A lossy one doesn't [2].
One naming detail trips people up. M4A is not a separate format. It's an MP4-based container, and the audio inside is usually AAC [2]. So when a phone saves a .m4a file, you are almost always looking at AAC.
Most built-in recorders already use it. Modern recording apps default to AAC inside an M4A container at 64 kbps or higher [3]. Apple Voice Memos also has a Lossless setting for people who want it [3].
How much storage does each format use?
WAV size is pure arithmetic: sample rate times bit depth times channels [4]. Silence takes as much room as speech.
AAC size depends on the bitrate you pick. Divide the bitrate by 8 to get bytes per second [4].
| Format and setting | Per minute | Per hour |
|---|---|---|
| WAV, 44.1 kHz, 16-bit, mono | about 5.3 MB | about 318 MB |
| WAV, 44.1 kHz, 16-bit, stereo | about 10.6 MB | about 635 MB |
| AAC, 64 kbps | about 0.48 MB | about 28.8 MB |
| AAC, 128 kbps | about 0.96 MB | about 57.6 MB |
WAV figures from [5]; AAC figures from the bitrate arithmetic in [4].
A two-hour lecture in mono WAV is about 636 MB. The same lecture in AAC at 128 kbps is about 115 MB. Over a term of weekly lectures, that gap adds up to gigabytes.
A note on recording AAC in TapeSail
TapeSail records AAC in two steps. It captures uncompressed audio while you record, then encodes the AAC file after the recording ends [6]. That means an AAC take briefly needs more free space than its final size: about 5.3 MB per minute of temporary space at 44.1 kHz mono, twice that in stereo [6]. For a two-hour mono session, that's roughly 640 MB before the AAC file is written, about the same as recording WAV. So in TapeSail, AAC saves space in the file you keep, not in the free space you need during the take.
Does WAV sound better than AAC for voice?
For listening back to speech, usually not in any way you'll notice. A bitrate of 128 kbps AAC is fine for speech, and 192 to 256 kbps is a common choice for music [2].
Quality drops when the bitrate gets very low. Below roughly 64 kbps mono, consonants like "f" and "s" start to smear, and that's where words such as "fifteen" and "fifty" get hard to tell apart [7]. If clear speech matters, stay at 64 kbps or above, and prefer 128 kbps.
When WAV is the better choice
The real difference shows up after recording, when you start changing the audio.
You plan to edit or process it heavily. Effects such as EQ, compression or time-stretching work on the samples they're given. Feed them a lossy file and the artifacts compound. Feed them WAV and they work on the complete recording [8]. Re-encoding a lossy file again and again is like photocopying a photocopy [8].
Someone else will mix it. If the recording goes to an editor or a music project, send the original WAV. They can always compress it at the end.
You need exact timing. The TapeSail help notes advise using WAV when exact sample duration matters [6].
You can't go back later. Converting an AAC file to WAV makes it bigger, but the sound is the same, because conversion can't restore data the encoder threw away [9]. If you think you'll need the full-quality version, record it that way from the start.
When AAC is the better choice
Everyday voice memos and notes. Small files, clear speech, easy to share.
Long lectures, meetings and interviews. You'll mostly listen back, and the storage saving over hours is large. Our guide to recording a lecture or meeting on your phone covers the rest of the setup.
Keeping a big library. If you record often and keep everything, AAC files take a fraction of the room. Just check free space before a long take, since the temporary space needed while recording is similar for both formats in TapeSail.
Sharing. An AAC file at 128 kbps is roughly a tenth the size of the same recording in stereo WAV, so it sends faster over messaging apps and email.
WAV and AAC in TapeSail
TapeSail is a voice recorder and audio editor for phones. It records WAV (uncompressed) or AAC (smaller files) [6], and you pick the format before you record, so you can use AAC for a meeting and WAV for a song idea on the same day.
A few details are worth knowing:
- Converting is free. WAV/AAC conversion is part of the free app, along with recording, basic edits and export [10].
- Edits keep the original. Trim, volume and fades save a new copy, so the take you recorded is never overwritten [11].
- Nothing leaves the phone unless you send it. Recordings stay on the device. Use Save to Files or Share to move a WAV or AAC file somewhere else.
- No account and no time limit or recording cap. Free space is the only limit, so check it before a long take.
If you're on Android, TapeSail is on Google Play.
Quick decision guide
- Recording a lecture, meeting or quick note? AAC.
- Recording music, a voice-over, or anything you'll process with effects? WAV.
- Not sure, and you have space? WAV. You can always make a small AAC copy later. The reverse doesn't bring quality back.
- Want to keep lots of recordings without filling the phone? AAC, at 64 kbps or higher for speech.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is M4A the same as AAC?
Not quite. M4A is the container, and AAC is the audio codec usually stored inside it [2]. For voice recordings on a phone, an .m4a file almost always holds AAC audio.
Can I turn an AAC recording into WAV to improve it?
No. The converted file is larger, but it holds the same audio, because a lossless format can't restore what the lossy encoder discarded [9]. Convert to WAV only when an app or editor asks for it.
Why do phone recorders default to AAC?
Because it keeps files small with speech that still sounds clear. Modern recorders default to AAC in an M4A container at 64 kbps or higher [3], which is enough for spoken word.
Sources
- masteringbox.com: explains that WAV stores uncompressed PCM audio and that lossy codecs remove sound through psychoacoustic masking.
- mediaconverter.io: defines lossy versus lossless, describes M4A as an MP4-based container for AAC, and gives 128 kbps for speech and 192 to 256 kbps for music.
- convertaudiototext.com: notes that modern recording apps default to AAC in M4A at 64 kbps or higher and that Apple Voice Memos offers a Lossless setting.
- parrotnotes.app: bitrate calculator showing WAV size as sample rate times bit depth times channels, and 57.6 MB per hour at 128 kbps.
- reqo.me: measured WAV sizes of 5.3 MB per minute (mono) and 10.6 MB per minute (stereo) at 44.1 kHz.
- tapesail.app: TapeSail help on WAV and AAC: AAC is saved after recording ends, capture needs about 5.3 MB per minute of temporary space at 44.1 kHz mono, and WAV is advised when exact sample duration matters.
- assemblyai.com: notes that fricatives start to smear below roughly 64 kbps mono.
- yttowav.org: explains that processing compounds artifacts in lossy files and that WAV keeps the complete recording for editing.
- montage.app: explains that converting a lossy file to a lossless format cannot restore discarded data.
- tapesail.app: lists recording, basic edits, WAV/AAC conversion and export as free.
- tapesail.app: explains that trim, volume and fades save a new copy and keep the original.
